Milk Crate Coffee

Excellent coffee (they use counter culture which is top tier). Best cheese danish I’ve ever had too. Perfectly heated with a delicious cheese filling and perfectly flat and buttery pastry. A++++. Going to come back and try the hot food too—also looked delectable!

Milk Crate Coffee is mamash one of Lakewood’s nicest coffee spots — the kind of place that feels like a real menuchas hanefesh in the middle of a hectic day. Whether you’re coming to get work done, meeting someone, or just need to sit down with a coffee and regain your sanity for a few minutes, this place is a total win.
First of all, the space and décor are beautiful. It’s modern, warm, and thoughtfully designed, with plenty of seating and a relaxed vibe that immediately puts you at ease. You can tell real thought went into it — not just “put out some tables and chairs,” but creating a place you actually want to be in. And yes… people are not exaggerating: even the bathroom is surprisingly nice. You walk in expecting regular, and suddenly you’re like, “Nu… okay, this is a whole experience.” 😄
The coffee itself is consistently excellent. You can taste the quality, and everything feels done properly — not rushed, not sloppy. The menu is solid and well thought out, and the food options are great too. The avocado toast is a fan favorite for a reason — fresh, filling, and perfect when you want something lighter but still satisfying. It’s the classic “I’m being healthy today” order… until you remember there’s dessert and say, eh, tomorrow I’ll start again. 😄
It’s also a fantastic place to get work done. Plenty of seating, calm enough to focus, and a vibe that makes it easy to stay a while without feeling pressure to leave. At the same time, it’s perfect for meeting a friend — not too loud, not too cramped, just comfortable enough to actually sit and schmooze like a mensch.
But what really takes Milk Crate Coffee to the next level is the people, especially the owner. He’s the kind of person who always has a kind word, remembers faces, and genuinely cares that you’re enjoying yourself. Ask him for a suggestion and he’s spot-on — and half the time, he’ll say, “Try this one,” and before you know it, it’s on the house. A coffee to try, a piece of cake, a dessert “just because.” And if he realizes it’s someone’s birthday? Suddenly something special appears at the table like it’s no big deal. Those small, thoughtful gestures make a huge difference.
It’s that heimish feeling — like you’re not just another customer, but someone he’s happy walked in. That warmth, combined with quality coffee and a beautiful space, is what keeps people coming back again and again.
Bottom line: Milk Crate Coffee is clean, stylish, welcoming, and genuinely enjoyable — great coffee, great atmosphere, and even better people. It’s the kind of place where a “quick coffee” turns into a full sit-down because it’s just too nice to leave. Highly recommended — and honestly, once you go, it becomes one of those spots you automatically suggest to others. 😄

Been wanting to come here since I heard they opened up a location in jersey! I came on a Sunday morning, no other customers were there, so service was super fast. They only have mugs to stay for 12 oz lattes, and I ordered a flat white so the employee asked if I minded if the flat white was in a larger mug. I didn’t mind, except when I got it, it was filled to the top. So definitely not a flats white. We also ordered the ricotta toast and the avocado toast, or sandwich I guess. The avocado plate was a little too homemade looking. And the ricotta toast was super sweet and watery.

Delicious food that feels great on the stomach—made with healthy, natural ingredients. Despite the quality, the prices are not overpriced. They bring the food to your table (except for drinks), and there’s no extra charge for waiter service.

The place has a fun, funky vibe with interesting props and decor—even the bathroom is worth checking out (see picture)! Highly recommend!

Hidden Gem!

Milk Crate Cafe is a true treasure! This charming spot serves up deliciously fresh coffee that's sure to satisfy any caffeine craving. But it's not just about the coffee – the unique atmosphere and lovely staff make for a truly special experience.

A must-visit for coffee connoisseurs and anyone seeking a warm, welcoming spot to relax and unwind. Can't wait to come back!