Plumsted Grill

We arrived at 4 o’clock. The place was packed. Did not have to wait long for a seat in front of the beautiful fireplace. Our server Lisa was very pleasant and a tentative to my husband. My husband and I, both ordered the Queen cut prime rib. My husband ordered rare, the “ redness that you have”. His came out at medium , very tough. I ordered mine medium rare, pink in the middle. It was served Grey. Yes, grey. It was so tough that I had to saw it with a knife to taste the three bites that I had from the center. Both our meals tasted like it was left over from yesterday. And was just warmed and served.The entire piece of meat was unedible. When the waitress came by to check on our meals, she was only interested in my husband‘s and quickly left before I was able to tell her how my steak was. 15 or 20 minutes, had gone by and she returned, and I advised her that steak was un edible.as it was clearly pushed to the side. At that point, she was apologetic and said the manager would be over. Another 20 minutes had passed , no manager. We finally ordered dessert to go and left. Lisa was very apologetic that they were supposedly known for their great prime rib, however, I would not even take this meat home to serve to my dog. I left the $40.00 Piece of meat on the table. The manager never found his way over to our table. It’s a shame, Because for the most part, their sandwiches are good. But after spending $150 on a meal that I left on the table, I think twice if going back.

​We recently held a repast luncheon at Plunsted Grill following a family funeral. During a difficult time, the team here provided a truly wonderful and comforting experience. The atmosphere was awesome, and the staff was incredibly friendly and attentive. The food was excellent—the Chicken Parm and Chicken Marsala were both fantastic. We greatly appreciate the wonderful service and meal provided by everyone at Plunsted Grill. Thank you for your kindness and professionalism.

I believe this was my 1st time here. Loved it! Nice woodsy atmosphere, my salad was fresh and crisp, my meal came with fresh baked bread with sesame seeds 🤎, had the queen cut prime rib w/garlic mashed (which was very nicely priced), the server Lisa was on the ball (brought extra napkins and made sure I found the ladies room ok, knew when I needed a new drink and she smelled nice). Really enjoyed my meal and experience. They could use a full length mirror in the ladies room. Will return.

Late lunch with my husband. Each of us ordered a hamburger which came with fries in the side. I have to say we received our monies worth. Good size portions, great taste, wonderful service and reasonable prices. Lodge-type atmosphere with bar area. Nicely done inside.

Biker themed bar and restaurant. Some outdoor seating available. Seated quickly, Took a long time to take our order. All the food came out correctly and portions were generous, we all took home leftovers.