Curds & Whey

Wonderful staff, cozy atmosphere, and the food is the absolute best I’ve ever had! 😁

Great acai bowl. My wife hates old coffees, but she loves the coffee from here.

We came across this little gem (that has been around for 13 years!) just today and this place single handedly just convinced us that we should move to this exact neighborhood haha!
We got two sandwiches, a pulled pork panini (basically a Cuban, yum!) and a chorizo with machego cheese and pear. They were both so delicious and I’ll be thinking about it for the next foreseeable days. Each sandwich order comes with chips but they’re not just any chips.. they’re TORRES chips! If you were to purchase these chips outside at the market, that itself is already $6 and the sandwiches are about $12-$16.. the value of this meal is HIGH! They use great quality cured meats and cheeses too.. I think we’re so used to being scammed in the city with the pricing we almost had a whiplash when they told us our total. LOL.
They also offer iced teas from any of the tea selections they have- very casually offering Harney & Sons.. I have no idea how she made the iced teas in less than two minutes but she did and it was perfect.
It seems like their specialty is charcuterie boards but they also offer frozen pasta and pints of icecream (they also serve icecream too, must go back for that), frozen food that’s ready to heat up and eat, unique jams, local pie and chocolates/ sweets.
This small business is family owned and operated- I believe the wonderful lady who helped us today was the owner and she was so sweet and welcoming.
We’re so excited to come back and try their other sandwiches and possibly order a charcuterie board for our next special occasion!

So many delicious things! Charcuterie, cheese, paninis, cookies, ice cream, coffee/tea, plus stuffed olives, dips, frozen items, McConnels’s ice cream cream! And a small selection of nice gifts.

This is by far my favorite place for cheese and charcuterie on Long Island. A small owner operated establishment that has the finest of meat, cheese and provisions from some of the most unique purveyors. When not taking items to go, you can sit down in a very relaxing atmosphere and feel like you’re in Italy while having a nice cheese and meat board. Must haves are her double cream, brie and spiced fig jam. The rosemary, marcona almonds also stand out. She makes fabulous boards and plates to go, a show stopper at any party!