Hainesville General Store Bakery

Wonderful place! You can get lunch (I think breakfast, too. I went in for a sandwich).
The baked goods are delicious. And they have gifts. Great atmosphere, friendly owners and staff. Definitely recommend!

I didn't get anything. They moved locations temporarily, are in a small building down the road... so if you're looking for a quaint general store vibe, I wouldn't go out of your way right now.
Rated 3 stars because a slice of refrigerated pie is $7. And I was in the mood for an anachronistic food venue.

My wife and I are on the #eatjersey challenge to visit and have a meal in all 564 towns of NJ. We chose Hainesville General Store Bakery for Sandyston, our 160th town.

We were confused when we first arrived. The original general store is mostly a bakery and souvenir shop with various prepackaged goods like candles, coffee beans, etc. Just a little bit down the road is the actual sandwich shop and kitchen where you can get hot breakfast sandwiches. There's no seating at the sandwich shop, but there is outdoor seating at the general store. We got our food in the sandwich shop and brought it back to eat at the tables on the porch of the general store. The shop is mostly for take-out customers.

Once we had that sorted out, our food was excellent! We got the Sun's Up Wrap, the Breakfast Pepperoni Ciabatta, and Chicken Fingers. The original general store has a rustic & historic appearance and feels like a trip back in time.

Hainesville General Store is a small, unassuming store located in Branchville, New Jersey.
Once you step inside though, you'll be surprised at how cute and charming the store is!
The selection of food and products is excellent, especially the sandwiches and baked goods. They also sell a variety of local food and products.

I visited this place on a recent trip to the Delaware Water Gap. I was looking for a place to grab a bite to eat and I was pleasantly surprised by the selection of food and the friendly service. I ordered a slice of peach pie, which was ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS! The pie was fresh, had the perfect amount of sugar, and was just the right size for a snack!

I also tried a few of the other baked goods, including the breads and cakes. Everything I tried was delicious and tasted fresh!
Their service was also excellent. The staff was friendly and helpful, and they were happy to make recommendations!

If you're in the area, I highly recommend visiting Hainesville General Store! It's a great place to grab a bite to eat, pick up some souvenirs, or just browse the selection of local food and products!

I’ve been coming here since I moved to montague in 2016. Hainesville General Store has one of the best breakfast sandwiches in Sussex county. As well as other really great hot food. And they also make delicious state fair winning pies. 10/10 recommend.