Vinnie's Pizza III

We’ve ordered from here for years. The pizza is decent and we’ve always appreciated the delivery. But the other night they sent us a half-mushroom pie — something we have never ordered. I called and politely asked if they could either re-deliver the correct pie or refund the portion we didn’t order. Instead, the woman refused and hung up on me.

It’s disappointing to see a place treat loyal customers this way. We’ve decided to switch and will be giving Stadium Pizza a try.

We used to order regularly from Vinnie's. Over time their good quality and service deteriorated. The pizza arrives not infrequently with the toppings sliding off the pizza and the dough has a slight sour taste. We ordered our regular order on 11/10/25 and we got sent the wrong order. We called to get the correct order and the woman on the phone pretty much said that we did order whatever arrived. After ordering for 2 years at least once a week, we are done with Vinnie's. It's unfortunate.

This pizza is great. It’s thin and very cheesy. I’ve been coming here for years. I moved to central jersey and no pizzeria has been able to match the taste of this pizza. I got the plain pie but have had the chicken buffalo. It’s just so good. I went in person and everyone is always nice.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Vinny's the Third Pizza, and I must say, it exceeded all my expectations! The moment I walked in, I was greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere. The staff were friendly and attentive, making sure our experience was top-notch.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza! I ordered 3 different pies and it was simply divine. The crust was perfectly crispy, the sauce had a delightful tang, and the fresh basil added a wonderful touch. Each bite was packed with flavor, and you could tell that quality ingredients were used. I recommend ranch for dipping.

What impressed me even more was the variety on the menu. Whether you’re a meat lover or a vegetarian, there’s something for everyone.

Overall, Vinny's the Third Pizza is a gem! I can’t wait to return and try more of their delicious offerings. Highly recommend!

Cousin Tony

Having lived on Long Island many moons ago, I'd have to say the pizza(Buffalo Chicken, & a Pepperoni) I've not had pizza like that since Long Island. The Calzone was what surprised me. All I could say was, damn that is so freaking good. Had it with just cheese and pepperonis on top. My only regret is I'm back in town today and will be leaving b4 they open😢. The rate of good reviews to negative is due to, if the experience was good, only 10% of folks will actually leave a comment. Great atmosphere at this place, guy said "I can fix it anyway you want" when I was asking about the Calzone. You can tell these guys know what their doing, and love what they do. I go coast to coast, after one meal here I'm convinced all the pizza in between these cross country trips has been absolutely cardboard😂. I'll be back every chance I get.