Crispino's Pizza

Recently went here for my first time last week and ordered an eggplant parm hero. I can honestly say it was the biggest eggplant parm hero I've ever gotten at a pizzeria. Eggplant was fresh and tasty. Cheese was excellent and sauce was delicious. Even the bread was great. It was so big that I had half for dinner one night, and the other half the next. Anytime I'm in West Islip, I'll be stopping here to try their other dishes.

Worth the 20 minute drive for me even with lots of pizzerias near me. Whoever the staff was working on Sunday 11/23/25 between 3-4pm when we placed the order, your good meals and amazing service should be recognized! Placed order over phone for a large pie, baked ziti and garlic knots and the gentleman taking the order was very pleasant and got our orders correctly exactly as we wanted (for example, asked for extra garlic on knots and he was able to accommodate us). Order was ready within 25 minutes which is great considering what we ordered. As for the food (as shown in photos), the pizza was yummy as always. The baked ziti was baked the perfect amount and added some fried chicken which had a tasty breading that was not falling apart or chewy, it was delicious! The pasta was boiled the perfect amount and the sauce was amazing. I love me some garlic knots and these are by far my favorite so kudos to the kitchen staff! The bread was so soft and fluffy but still baked the perfect amount for that crispy bite. Great portions and packaged well. Everything was amazing and this is why we will keep coming back :)

Side note: they decorate for the holidays and it looks very cozy and welcoming

Just what we were looking for - a quick slice of delicious pizza!

Absolutely the BEST PIZZERIA EVER!!!! My kids and I come here anytime we want pizza. Just ordered their grandma pie! Amazing! Their vodka slice and cream spinich slice are my favorite!!! Everyone working there is super sweet and freindly!!! Love love love it

Stopped in for a slice of sicilian with my son, as it is his proffered slice, a quick search lead us back here. We'd been here before, after a few of my daughter's activities - always meant to leave a review.
He got his 2 sicilian slices, I got one too - but, couldn't resist trying one of their specialty slices - a sausage and peppers (one of my favorite dishes) slice. I'd had one before, elsewhere - we won't talk about that much.
This sausage and peppers slice was near perfection! Not soggy, in fact, quite crispy - but, definitely not lacking in the signature oil blend that makes sausage and peppers a personal favorite. The topping coverage was entirely, but not overwhelming to the point of taking over the pizza - personally perfect.
The sicilian slices - my son ranked higher than his personal favorite spot, which is a HUGE response from him - as he enjoyed the balance of crunchy and "squishy" as he calls the doughy topside of a sicilian slice. I have to agree, really top notch! Definitely come again!