Formaggio Mio Cafe

This is our second time here. We ordered the same two dishes. They did not come out at the same time. We had to ask about the second one (risotto) which was not as good as last time. We also ordered fish and chips. The fries were undercooked. This time they did bring ketchup and the fish and chips came with garlic mayo (which was not great). We had to ask for water a few times and got it near the end of our meal. We never got the napkins we requested. No one came to check if we wanted or needed anything.
The view from the porch is gorgeous.
When two appetizers and tap water plus tip is a $50 outing, I want better.

Came to this restaurant about 2 weeks ago.
Me and my friend got there to be greater with we are closed, I told them your Google said you're open still (we came around 3 or 4 pm, Shabbat was till late).
We told them could we at least see the restaurant, cause of course we were coming from far and made a detour just to try this restaurant cause it looked interesting online.
The first look at the restaurant was that this place looked old and not that great. The only nice thing they have is that it faces the lake.
All of the sudden a difren waiter said they can take our order if we quickly order cause they where closing the kitchen (I dont like to rush in places where I dont see the food but I had to) we ordered 1 ravioli order and 1 salad.
Once we ordered another 2 people came in and also ordered, they didn't tell them it was closed. So, as a person who is paying overpriced food, I dont like to get bad service vs. other clients of theirs that came in 10 min later.

The ravioli for the price and the look of the venue was not normal. Only 6 small ravioli
And the Greek salad didn't even know how to use the feta. They put in cubes for which it wasn't able to blend into the salad, the salad also was really small, you cant see on this picture cause I took closer up but their dishes are small diameter, most was lettuce and air.

We paid about almost $60 . And truthfully, it's not worth it at all. For that, the venue should have atleastblooked elegant, not like if you're eating my a camp inside.

Bottom like if you want to pay city prices for not so great food this is the place to go.

Formaggio Mio is the kosher dining experience that was missing upstate. Amazing tasteful yet artisanal food, each dish is a creation of its own. With a great outdoor and indoor ambiance, the meal is enjoyable and luxurious. As with all businesses, expect to wait a little longer during peak hours but the food redeems any wait and makes it worth it!
Highly recommend!