Pizza One

My husband and I don't always agree about what type of pizza to get but we do agree about what makes a great pizza. He is from here and I'm from LI, and for the 20 years I've lived in Scarsdale, I just haven't found a pizza place in driveable distance that has flavorful sauce, the right crust, and quality cheese... until Pizza One. We both really enjoy their pies: plain, gourmet, and grandma. Their pinwheels, garlic knots, salads, and cheesecakes have all been enjoyable as well. Want a comfy lunch joint with internet? They have that too. I really expected them to be much busier by now. Hoping they grow their business so I can keep my favorite new pizzeria around!

Been here twice, the pizza was nothing special. The eggplant topping however was pretty delicious; the plain slice was a combo of old dough and cheese. Wasn’t worth the $

Absolutely loved this place! From the moment we walked in, the staff greeted us with warm smiles and made us feel right at home. The service was quick, polite, and super friendly — you can tell they really care about their customers.

Now let’s talk about the food… wow. The pizza was fresh out of the oven, with a crispy crust, rich tomato sauce, and perfectly melted cheese. You can taste the quality in every bite. The ice cream was smooth, creamy, and came in so many delicious flavors — I wanted to try them all! And don’t even get me started on the desserts — beautifully presented and totally addictive. Whether you have a sweet tooth or just want a good slice of pizza, this place delivers on all fronts.

Great food, amazing staff, cozy vibe — definitely one of my new favorite spots. I’ll be coming back again and again!

Pizza is simply great. Staff was friendly and had many other things beside pizza like ice cream, desserts, and bread. Looks very nice inside and outside. Also has a great variation of pizza ( about 20 different types.) Very bright inside, even in the night! Would highly reccomend to all pizza lovers!!! 🍕🍦🧁😊

We really wanted to try a place with a variety of slice options and decided to check this place out. The inside is really nice and has a modern vibe; even the plates inside were really nice! They had a great variety and the food for the most part was pretty decent. I got the Sicilian slice with no moz (a very exciting find since I can’t eat moz) but it really lacked flavor for me. We didn’t get any marinara with our knots so they were quite dry. Otherwise it was pretty good. I’d try it again with different choices and see if it’s better.