The Lindenhurst Diner

Good old school Long Island Greek diner. My Jack Daniel's glazed meatloaf was very good. The Caesar salad was super. Good cheesecake. The grilled cheese was described as 'tasty'. The Greek wrap was mentioned as 'exactly what I wanted!'

First time here. I had been on the road all day with my brother. They had a late night special almost like happy hour. I had wings and my brother got the hangover fries. Wings were perfect. crispy, juicy and seasoned well. Hangover fries are not a light meal! Very generous portion and great flavor. I recommend sharing.

WOW! BLOWN AWAY! From the smiling and engaging attentive staff to the outstanding meals. You WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED! I had an extraordinary experience with my wife and kids. The food was hot, fresh made with love! Please enjoy the ambiance and great selection of food including my favorite Vodka Chicken Parm fries and Bodega Chopped cheese.Don't skip desert either, The fudge brownie and Rainbow cake were f given by the toughest critics I know, my son and daughter. Thank you all for making this a memorable experience for your new neighbor celebrating 1 month in Lindy!

I left underwhelmed. I tried the maple bacon pancakes, a build-your-own Angus burger with sautéed onions and bacon, and an Oreo shake with banana. Everything sounded great on paper, but the execution fell flat.
The quality of the food didn’t live up to the hype—definitely not “high-quality” as they claim in response to other reviews. Their products/ingredients are not satisfactory

The pancakes were obnoxious to the point it was too much to consume and , the burger was forgettable, and the milkshake was average at best—nothing you couldn’t get at any typical spot. For the price, you’d expect something a bit more memorable. The lack of care or effort is noticeable.

I wouldn’t recommend it unless you’re nearby and need a quick bite. Otherwise, it’s just another diner with inflated expectations.