Wurtsboro Diner and Cafe

Cozy diner with very good breakfast and comfort food at a moderate price. The best thing about this diner is their friendly and attentive staff! We go there everytime whenever we're in the vicinity of Wurtsboro.

My friend had been in this town previously and wanted to try this diner. The entrance was kinda non-discript but that all changed with the friendly greeting as soon as we entered and immediate seating. Our waitress was bright and bubbling with a great smile and offered us drinks. When she returned with the drinks we had just quickly looked over the specials. It's out of character for me but I immediately asked Chrystal for a recommendation, she asked a few questions about my likes to narrow it down, then said "do you like Philly cheese steak?" then told me obout their cheese steak burger. I ordered that and sweet potato fries. My friend ordered a steak sandwich and fries. The food was out fast and our waitress stopped by a few times to chat with us, OMG!!! our first bites were amazing! I couldn't wait to thank her for the suggestion! Both of us continued to be more and more in love with the food! Normally I cut the sandwich in half to take half home, I couldn't stop eating it and ate another quarter! I knew that the fries would reheat nicely at home. We paid our tab and gave Chrystal a hug, her due date is my birthday and we wished her well. I can't wait for Cathy to bring me back!!

My partner and I absolutely love this local diner! The food is always top-notch whether we’re coming in for a cozy breakfast or a quick lunch, it hits the spot every time. Everything tastes homemade and fresh, with generous portions and great flavor.

But what really makes this place special is the service. The staff is incredibly friendly and hardworking, and it shows. The waitresses always greet us with warm smiles, making us feel right at home from the moment we walk in. Deanna is especially amazing she’s attentive, kind, and always on the ball. You can tell she genuinely cares about her customers.

It’s become one of our favorite spots, and we always look forward to our next visit. Great food, great people, great vibe!

We stopped in for breakfast on a Sunday morning. The customer service was definitely the highlight of our visit. The waitress was very friendly and attentive, which we appreciated.

Unfortunately, the food didn’t live up to the same standard. We each ordered a plate with eggs and were disappointed to find them bland and undercooked. They tasted as if they'd been poached or cooked in water with no seasoning whatsoever. The home fries weren’t much better. They were mushy on the inside with a thick, flavorless crust on the outside.

To make things worse, the temperature of the food was noticeably cold, which really took away any remaining appeal. For a small diner like this, the food should be the standout, but in this case, it was a real letdown.

It’s a shame because the service was great, but unfortunately, that couldn’t make up for such poorly prepared food.

Kind people, quality food. Classic diner food, my dear old dad was beyond pleased. This is a place where they butter the toast for you. Fast service. A clean, small, family diner. Top place for breakfast in the area. Very inexpensive.