Biagio's

Place has been highly recommended for years and yesterday was the day. An unassuming place tucked away in Sterling, NJ. Was there mid morning, so decided on a Taylor Ham, Eggs and Cheese sandwich, which turned into a difficult process trying to place an order for some reason. In the end, the order was correct, but a challenge to place. That was the only small thing, because they delivered on high level with the order. The Breakfast sandwich was good. Definitely prepared differently than rest of thr state with the Taylor ham on one side and egg on the other. The stromboli was legit. The weight of it alone was one the best.

The Star of the show, was the Jelly donut which moves into my #1 spot for NJ Donut on Scary Good Eats. So good. Packed with Jelly on every bite and the texture of the donut was outstanding. What a hidden gem. Worth taking the ride for the Donuts alone. I know they have more to offer with their menu and I look forward to partaking in some other items. The Jelly Donut champ is here. Can't wait to go back.

Old school, remains old school….. Thank god!!! The bread is the real deal…. Crunchy, texture and taste…. But the donuts are to die for the custard ones are spectacular and the jelly ones are sinful… A must stop by is an order…. Totally delicious 😋

We had an excellent experience at Biagio’s. These folks know how to run a good restaurant, it is a special place and somewhat of a hidden gem.

Experience - the experience is very good. The location is easy, we like that you can park in front. The atmosphere is nice.

Service - the service is also very good.

Food - All of the food is absolutely outstanding, including the specials.

So, overall, the value is very good. We like that it is BYO.

I always have a great experience dining here. From the moment we walk in, the atmosphere is always warm and welcoming, with attentive staff who make us feel right at home. The food is always good and the service is excellent; our server checked in often without being intrusive, and everything arrived promptly.

This is an amazing place that truly has it all—bakery, deli, and dinner all in one spot! My top recommendation from the restaurant is the Osso Buco. It’s absolutely incredible! The flavors are rich and perfectly balanced, and the portion size is generous. For those with a sweet tooth, their dessert selection is fantastic, offering a wide variety of delicious options. Definitely a must-visit!