Black Sheep Bar and Provisions

Food was so delicious and everyone was so kind and the service was so fast. Our server Marc was very attentive and checked on us very often. Creative dishes with unique taste. The beef tartare was delicious. Connor, Artie and Avalon were great and so kind to us. Will definitely be coming back!

I’ve been meaning to write this review for a couple weeks but our meal at Black Sheep was not only delicious but memorable because of the customer service provided by Kyle. He was so personable and gave such great recommendations after hearing what we were considering and made some suggestions that we would’ve missed if he didn’t mention it!! The drinks were top notch (Limoncello Spritz and an old fashioned), the apps were yum (fried olives and some of the best wings around and a salad that I’m still dreaming about!) mains included lobster rolls and risotto and we rounded it off with a perfect slice of olive oil cake and gelato! 10/10 for everything and can’t wait to go back and try more!

First time visiting and we definitely will be back. We ordered a ton, and everything was outstanding. Highlights were the squash rings, chicken wings, the little pizza, and the pasta. If I had to give one piece of criticism I would say the music could have been a bit louder, they have an amazing playlist going! One of the best meals we have had in NJ.

This is our second time at this charming restaurant. Both times the food has been really good. We started with a yummy Rose and a beer. We then ordered a scallop crudo which was very good and flavorful! I then ordered the branzino which was roasted whole with potatoes and a spicy sauce. It was really yummy. My husband ordered a boneless rib eye with rosemary fries! It was very well cooked. We ended with an olive oil cake which was good but I think could have been better. It was a bit dense and but super flavorful. But overall we had a fabulous meal! I would highly recommend it.

I'm only giving a 4 star because out of what we ordered, the shrimp was overcooked and honestly no flavor at all. The Tuna Crudo is a MUST have, the wings were very flavorful as were the Garlic fries. Laugh at this but EVEN the ketchup had an amazing taste, we ordered a second batch of it for our fries. We went on a Tuesday evening for some shareables and drinks and it was crowded. A reservation would definitely be needed if you don't want to miss out, the place is very small. My boyfriend felt a bit rushed (the food did come out in a matter of minutes) but overall, it was a good experience.