Incredible Cookies

Strange location. Signage outside makes it seem like a bakery, but it more looks like a wedding planning boutique. There was a small counter that had cookies, but the selection was small. Walked in, didn't see any staff, and walked out.

The BEST 🍪🍪 in NJ!🙌😋🌟🌟🌟🌟 🌟
My husband and I recently ordered custom wedding party favors from Incredible Cookies, and we couldn't be more thrilled with the experience! They did an amazing job with the packaging, which was beautifully designed and perfectly executed. The chocolate chip cookies themselves were absolutely delicious – soft, chewy, and full of flavor. Our family, friends, and guests loved them, and they were a hit at our wedding.

What truly impressed me was the exceptional customer service. Incredible Cookies was prompt, professional, and accommodating throughout the entire process. They ensured that the cookies were made fresh and delivered on time, and the communication was top-notch.

I highly recommend Incredible Cookies to anyone looking for custom treats for their special occasion. Their attention to detail, commitment to quality, and lovely business practices make them a standout. They truly went above and beyond to make our wedding day extra special, and we're so grateful for their contribution. Thank you, Incredible Cookies, for making our celebration even more memorable! 🙌🍪💕

With much gratitude,
Zainab & Eiatzaz

I’m not one to write reviews often, but this one truly deserves to be shared. My grandfather, who had been struggling with the possession of two demons for years, has been given a second chance at life, thanks to one of these divine cookies.

Let me explain: When my grandfather gazed upon these cookies, something miraculous happened. The very moment he took a bite, he was instantly cured. Yes, cured. The demons left, as though the very sweetness of these cookies acted as a balm for his tortured soul. I’m not exaggerating when I say that this was nothing short of a modern-day miracle. I’ve already reached out to the Vatican, but apparently, they require three witnesses for full recognition. So I’m waiting, but in the meantime, I highly encourage anyone whose loved ones might be grappling with dark forces (demonic or otherwise) to send them to this place.

It’s not just about the taste—though let me tell you, the cookies are *exceptionally* delicious—it’s about the power they hold. The mix of flavors seems to transcend mere baked goods and border on the supernatural. If you know anyone dealing with the evil within, you might just want to send them here.

To the team behind these cookies: thank you for unknowingly offering salvation along with your sweets. I don’t know if you’re aware of your powers, but you’ve changed our lives.

P.S. I do see another review from someone who had a similar experience, so this definitely isn’t a one-off. Something is going on here!

If you need your loved ones freed from the darkness, get them a cookie. It could save their soul.

I honestly don't know where to begin. This place isn't just a bakery—it's a transformative, magical wonderland. Let me set the stage: years ago, my grandpa was a man lost in his demons. He carried a weight that I didn't think he’d ever shake, something he’d struggled with for decades. But then, one day, he walked into this cookie place. And it was there, in the comforting embrace of their oven-baked goodness, that something changed. Thank you.

Incredible Cookies truly lives up to its name! The staff is unbelievably friendly genuinely warm, welcoming, and always ready with a smile or great recommendation.

You feel like family the moment you walk in. And the pricing? Practically unbeatable for the quality you’re getting. It’s about $2 per. Every cookie is fresh, flavorful, and made with care. Whether you’re a chocolate chip or an m&m lover/purist or an adventurous cookie lover, this place nails it. Highly recommend stopping by you won’t regret it. Plenty of parking and tons of stuff to see/try.