Island Beach Fish Company

Disclaimer:
I get it that it was end of the season and few items were not on the menu… i also get they were understaffed as a result.

We stopped by for lunch today… they got outdoor patio with tiki bar and live music outside. There was a large group having a party but still plenty of seats outside. Dogs are welcome - besides ours - there were two other families with dogs and everyone got along.
There is also an indoor room, but didnt go in since it was warm and we decided to enjoy it outside. Staff was kind and nice and service was quick (once i got their attention).

Menu has a large sushi/roll section as well as some fried seafood options.

Ladies went for clams and oysters…they liked oysters, not so much clams…

Wife ordered their specialty Nightrider roll - was 3 stars at best both taste and freshness…
Honestly - you want sushi? Go to a sushi place…

I had soft po boy sandwich. Soft shell crab is the main overfried and too much bread! Eh..

My friend had sausage broccoli sandwich. Same sentiment.

Fish tacos were ok…

I hear pizza was good but we didnt try…. Overall - we left full but likely would not return for food. Maybe for the vibe and pizza we would..

SEASIDE PARK: Island Beach Fish Company
🐾 Leashed and friendly pups are welcome at the beautiful outdoor space featuring swinging bar seats, picnic tables, and 2 breezy patio bars.
🍹 Full bar + tasty food menu to keep you satisfied.
🏈 Plenty of TVs so you will not miss the game.
🌊 Just a block from the ocean, you can practically feel the sea breeze.
💯 Fun fact: the same owners also run Bum Rogers Crabhouse & Tavern and Berkeley Cut!

2025 update. Great place still. Fantastic food and service. You won’t be disappointed.

2023
Great Seafood and Service. Sat inside at the bar. Friendly Bar Tender named Charlie.
Great outdoor seating too. We will be back.

Pros: Kitchen staff was nice and very helpful. Pizza, flounder, mozzarella sticks, and tuna poke bowl were tasty!
Cons: Besides pizza, portions are very small (3 scallops for $18 and only two were edible, third undercooked). It is very loud indoors so wait the half hour to be seated outside. Bar was understaffed, having to wait on all bar patrons and tables ordering food. Food staggered so that last plate brought out had to be boxed to go. Bill had an unexpected added price for paying credit (instead of cash). Waitstaff added their own $100 tip.

Very grateful to the owner who looked into the incorrect added charge. Jerry gave us peace of mind and was beyond helpful in our dilemma.

All the food was amazing and cooked perfectly. Very flavorful. The bartender was so friendly and made delicious cocktails. My fiance proposed right before taking me there so it was a night I will never forget! ❤️