Mystic Lobster Roll & Sushi

First time ever getting a lobster roll. The owners were very friendly. A family and I mean a whole family operation which is nice to see. Just renovated inside and has a very nice layout. Prices for being on the Island are basically what I thought it would be. You do get a quite a lot of food for what you pay for. Lobster Roll was delicious, for my first one I was very pleased.

We ordered a salmon avocado roll, lobster Rangoon, and two Connecticut-style warm lobster rolls — everything was incredibly fresh! The bread was soft & fresh, the fries were crispy, and the lobster was tender and flavorful. The highlight, though, was the amazing service. Everyone was so friendly and attentive. We’ll definitely be coming back to Mystic Lobster!

Found an ad for this place on Reddit of all places, back when it was located on Fischer Blvd I guess, but wanted a close by Lobster Roll place so gave it a shot.

Overall, the food was delicious, but felt like the lobster rolls could be a bit.. more. I get that it's lobster and lobster is pricey, the rolls were well stuff, but they're basically hotdog buns. I feel like I've always had better buns to hold lobster rolls, toasted a bit and buttered for Connecticut rolls, they just felt a bit small I suppose.

The chicken fritters were great, a lot for your money, the slaw and beans with the lobster rolls are just ok. The fries are also great, and out key lime pie was delicious.

The place looks great, parking and seating were no issues, music might be a touch loud, but atmosphere is very fitting.

Overall, it was a great visit, a little bit let down that the lobster rolls weren't a bit more "Wow", but was still good. For the app, 2 lobster rolls, and dessert, plus tip, hundred bucks. A good place to scratch that itch for sure.

First time ever, I visited this place with a friend from out of state as well as the first time I ate a lobster roll and some big 'ol crab legs.
We ordered the one that was warm with butter, and it was delicious! Being new to crab legs as well, this was a whole different flavor field. (You would think all these years in Jersey, I'd be more into seafood, lol)
I enjoyed the whole experience. My friend ordered the Manhattan clam chowder, and he said it was delicious. I tasted the chowder part, and it was tasty, but I wasn't taking in clams and lobster on the same day. 😭 baby steps. The two females that worked there were super nice and loquacuous. Very very friendly. Place is small. Would definitely try again.

So I come in to this restaurant and they are slammed. It’s the Jersey shore during summer, I get it. I was seated within 15 mins and it was 100% worth the wait. Everything was awesome. I’m from Ct, we made the lobster roll, so naturally, I ordered the Connecticut lobster roll and for an appetizer I got fried oyster deviled eggs, And let me tell you everything was amazing! My server was awesome. Environment was great. It felt like I stepped into a New England store. It was 100% exactly what I expected from a lobster shop in Connecticut but on the Jersey shore. I’d have to recommend this place 100% 10 out of 10 it’s amazing.