Nickolas Pizza Restaurant

My son and his team stopped in after their soccer game for a slice, and they were so accommodating, and friendly! Pizza was hot and delicious!! Definitely recommend

A true gem. Best kept secret in Brick as far as I'm concerned. The food is exceptional. I especially like the specialty pies. Staff is nice even when they're busy. The atmosphere is such that you could drop it in the middle of the city boroughs and it would fit perfectly. Authentic right down to the picture of Padre Pio on the wall. You won't be disappointed.

Called and asked if they could do half with no cheese and they said absolutely. Came out perfect! So delicious!

Nickolas Pizzeria serves some of the best Italian food around, with authentic recipes that bring real flavor to the table. The Margherita pizza is a standout — the sauce is fresh and delicate, the basil adds the perfect touch, and their homemade mozzarella takes it to another level. That cheese alone makes the visit worthwhile, as it’s far beyond what you’d expect at a regular pizzeria.

What truly makes this spot memorable is the combination of genuine Italian taste and the warm, welcoming atmosphere created by the owners. It’s not often you find a place where both the food and the people leave such a lasting impression. Whether you live nearby or are just visiting, this is a place every pizza lover should try.

🌟 Absolutely recommended!

Nickolas Pizza is an old school gem. It is family owned and operated. Massimo Greets you like a long lost relative. The place is spotless and the selection of traditional Italian fair is limitless. They use the finest and freshest ingredients, including homemade mozzarella if you ask for it. I cannot highly recommend this place. It feels like we are drowning in massive, corporate, impersonal food chains. This is a reminder of how things are supposed to be. In addition to enjoying yourself, you were going to leave feeling like you actually matter. Thank you, Massimo and Family for another wonderful experience. God Bless Blue & Gold! God Bless America! Remember Everyone Deployed Everyday!