Priscilla's Pantry

Priscilla's Pantry in Basking Ridge is a delightful local spot, not a franchise, which gives it a warm and welcoming vibe during my Jan 2025 travel trip. The people here truly make the place special with their friendly and attentive service. On my first two visits, I tried the cortado, which was absolutely spot-on, and some of their breakfast sandwiches, which were fresh, flavorful, and satisfying. They also have a great selection of pastries, including croissants, muffins, and scones, all baked to perfection and perfect for pairing with their coffee.

Unfortunately, on my third visit, the cortado was a letdown--it just didn't meet the high standards of my earlier experiences. That aside, their breakfast menu offers a nice variety, including egg sandwiches, avocado toast, and more.

Parking is convenient and easy to find, which adds to the appeal. Despite the inconsistency on my last visit, I'd still recommend Priscilla's Pantry for its charming local feel, delicious breakfast options, and tasty pastries. It's definitely worth a try, and I'm hoping my next visit will be back to the high quality I enjoyed initially!

Stopped in here for lunch on a whim partway through a long drive and I am so glad we did! I got a spicy chicken wrap and it was genuinely amazing, so fresh and delicious. I loved how much pre-made and fresh to-go options they had. I wish I lived closer and could come in more, but will make a point to stop off here if I’m ever back in town!

This place is so cool they are super creative with their custom orders. Ordered custom small sized appetizers from them for an event and it was executed so well. Perfectly sized portions for the crowd.

Cute little spot with friendly staff and delicious food. Parking is on the smaller side but easy access and free. So many options of pre-made foods as well as fresh meals. I really enjoyed a sausage egg and cheese on a croissant. They have some seating in the back that’s pretty cozy. They have signs asking you to try and be cognizant of their small parking so not to stay more than 45 minutes at a table. I’d love for there to be a couch or someone cozier to curl up with a book! Unsure if there’s an upstairs so will need to explore more next time.

Now for my standard comments. Location is pretty “lived in” but clean. Cozy and comfortable vibes.

Excellent ! Priscilla’s pantry is an absolute gem - You can go grab daily made food which is also creative and many healthy options . Don’t forget the delicious desserts

In addition she offers full catering - this can be customized to your specific needs.

Most days you will meet
Priscilla who is hard at work -

This is a definite Yes !