Cold Spring Pizza

We absolutely loved this place! After a long 6-hour hike from Beacon to Cold Spring, we came here a bit late and the classic pies were already gone, so we tried a slice of Grandma Margherita Pizza and one Eggplant pizza. The Grandma Margherita was simply amazing – wow! The Eggplant slice is more for those who enjoy that flavor, but still interesting to try.

The atmosphere was warm and welcoming, and the staff were super friendly. This spot always feels like the right choice when we come to Cold Spring. After such a tough hike, that pizza was exactly what we needed. Highly recommended to everyone!

Slices look like a painting. Bae always gets a beef patty.
Sat at the outside table. Everything was delicious and very filling. Price was reasonable. Took half of the extra cheese slice to go for later. Great place fuel up before a nearby Washburn trail hike.

I stopped by this pizzeria on my visit to Cold Spring just this morning with my aunt and mom. We had a whole margarita pie and it was delicious!!!! The sauce on the pizza was to die for. The vibe inside is very old school, almost like it came out of a 90s movie from a small town. The service was great as well! My mom and aunt loved the pizza, and we even ended up bringing the extra slices to my dad and brother who both said it was excellent!! I definitely recommend them!!

I came here with a buddy of mine to feast after hiking through the Cornish Estate trail (definitely worth checking out). Normally when I visit a restaurant, I try things that are interesting and different. Looking through the variety of slices available, I asked the gentleman behind the counter to recommend me some slices. I ended up with a Margherita slice, a BBQ Pulled Pork slice, and the Eggplant Garlic Knot sandwich. My friend had gotten a pepperoni slice and the spicy pepperoni with hot honey (not pictured).

I didn't get to try his slices, but he really liked the pepperoni slice. He enjoyed the spicy one as well, but he said it was a little too spicy and sweet for his taste. He did end up getting an additional pepperoni slice. I went for the BBQ slice first, and it was FANTASTIC! Literally perfect in every way. The margherita slice however was rather plain. It wasn't bad by any regard, but I thought it was going to be just as good as the BBQ slice. Perhaps my taste buds were all over the place from the first slice. The biggest surprise here was the Garlic Knot Sandwich however. To be honest I wasn't expecting to like it; I only got it for the sake of trying something different, but I'm glad I did. Of the three, this was my absolute favorite. The combination of the pesto with the balsamic glaze and eggplant melded so perfectly.

The staff inside was extremely friendly and welcoming, and the accompanying ambiance was calm and relaxing. The interior was also very clean. Overall this place was absolutely fantastic. The only thing that kept them from getting 5 stars was the margherita slice I had. It wasn't bad, but I felt that it was lacking, especially in comparison to the other items I had. Definitely making the journey to come here again