JP's

JP's is a bit laid back, with laid back music, but that's what I love about it. It's not bougie like some of the other restaurants on City Island. And because it's off the main street it doesn't get the attention it deserves. Also, to some their prices may seem high, but the large portion size you're getting is why it's priced that way. In any other restaurant, if you ordered ravioli, you'd probably get 5 pieces on your plate. JP's gives enough to feed 2-3 people! My meal usually yields 2 days worth if leftovers. Plus you get a salad and that delicious buttery garlic bread!
Also they serve REAL drinks, not the watered-down stuff you get at other places. And I love that the owner is the bartender, so he's always there to greet the customers.
And finally, the views of the river on the right side are all worth it!
Update: JP's is expanding... Klassy Kuisine will be opening soon in the shared space on the left side.

Great atmosphere that pairs nicely with the amazing seafood. Ordered two broiled combos for 2 people as we had 4 people. Enough food to feed 6-7 people. :)

Great food and service.. would have given 5 stars but atmosphere didn’t add to the experience. Pricier than some spots but food and service were great.

JP's still doing it well after all these years. Our first date here 37 years ago before moving out of state. Returned for our 35th ANNIVERSARY. Dinner was incredible, John treated my wife and I so wonderfully on our anniversary. Maureen (Mo), our server, was excellent and made sure to make our dinner outing special on our day. What a polite and caring young lady( your parents did well)!!! God's willing we will be back next year (Florida)...THANK YOU JP's!!

You get what you pay for. The best shrimp I’ve had in over 10 years and I’m not kidding. Had the shrimp cocktail ( legit jumbo shrimp ) and shrimp scampi and still can’t believe how fresh and tasty it was, much better than 90% of other places I get shrimp from. Owner is very nice and sociable. Service was outstanding. 10/10 rating overall