Matteo's of Huntington

We had my mother's 80th birthday party there. The manager Dennis and the staff were fantastic! Everything went really well. The food was very good,and everyone enjoyed themselves. Very reasonable! I would highly recommend it!

We booked an 80th surprise bday party for 60ppl for my Mom at Matteos. I felt a bit awkward booking the party without physically seeing the venue. Although reviews were solid and they were recommended by a family friend. I'm glad we did. I worked with Dennis via email, he was great. The day of the event came, there was no issues, we wanted for nothing. The staff was incredible and beyond accommodating. The food was tasty and plentiful. Our guests had nothing but positive things to say. Overall, we'd go back again.

The service was bad, the busboys don't do their job, and my food took a millennia to come out. I got a the short rib with pumpkin risotto, one of their specialties. The short rib was good but the risotto was horrific. My family got the Osso Bucco, pan seared salmon, and branzino. The branzino was not deboned well. The drinks also weren't great. I most likely won't be coming back.

Matteo’s of Huntington: The Trifecta of Taste, Style & Heart! 💫

We Long Islanders are spoiled with excellent Italian cuisine—but Matteo’s of Huntington doesn’t just join the ranks, it leads them. Some restaurants dazzle with culinary artistry, others with ambiance or service—but very few shine in all three. Matteo’s, however, hits this coveted trifecta with flying colors. 🎯

A Flavorful Symphony for Your Senses 👄🎶

Every bite is a love letter to your palate, exploding with flavor and finesse. The kitchen masterfully blends traditional and innovative recipes from both Northern & Southern Italy 🇮🇹, elevating your meal into a full-on experience.

The recently renovated space is a stylish, modern-chic dream—think rich wood accents, sleek marble finishes, glowing ambient 🕯️ lighting, and mesmerizing fireplaces 🔥 that dance and flicker, setting a cozy yet energetic vibe throughout. With mellow background music 🎼 and a lively buzz 🐝 , the atmosphere is warm, welcoming, and alive.

Where Hospitality Becomes Magic 🪄

From the moment we stepped through the door 🚪 , we were welcomed like family. Dennis, the managing proprietor, greeted us with a genuine smile, and hostess Hanna radiated warmth with her smile. The whole staff exudes passion and joy—it’s contagious! 😷

A special shoutout to our server Melvin, whose courteous, polished, and charismatic service turned dinner into something truly special. ⭐️

The Feast Begins… 🍽️✨

We kicked things off with the Shrimp Scampi Pizzetta 🍤🍕 and a Tricolor Salad 🥗.

Let me just say—this pizzetta 🍕 is next-level. Tender gulf shrimp 🍤, EVOO, capers, garlic 🧄, arugula, and a hint of citrus 🍋‍🟩, all atop a perfectly crisp crust oozing with melted mozzarella 🧀. It’s a flavor bomb 💣 that you must try.

The Tricolor Salad was no sidekick—it brought fresh burrata, roasted peppers 🫑, almonds, and greens 🥬 together with a luscious balsamic glaze. Add those fluffy pizza bread points 🍞 for scooping? Chef’s kiss. 👨‍🍳❤️

The Showstoppers: Entrées That Wow 🍽️🔥

Each entrée dazzled (yes, I sampled everyone’s 😋).
•   Soft Shell Crabs Piccata 🦀: A dreamy combo of artichoke hearts 💞, grape tomatoes 🍅, capers, and lemony angel hair pasta 🍝 bathed in a delicate white wine sauce 🍷. Light, bright, and full of zing.
•   Grilled Shrimp 🦐 “Wendy”: Subtly powerful. Perfectly grilled shrimp 🍤 paired with charred string beans 🫛 and a zingy Dijon mustard dressing. Simple, yet bold.
•   Baby Rack of Lamb 🐑: Coated in a Dijon-panko crust, served with fingerling potatoes 🥔 and broccoli rabe 🥦, and finished with fresh chimichurri 🥄. Every bite was a bold, savory dance 🕺.
•   The Pork Chop “Ultima” 🐖: Topped with spicy cherry peppers 🌶️🍒 and melted mozzarella 🧀, this bone-in beauty was crisp on the outside, juicy on the inside. A true “wow” dish. 😱

Sweet Finale: Dessert Dreams 🍮🍓

Though we were stuffed, we were surprised with the dessert they brought to the table. The warm Dulce de Leche crepe with fresh strawberries 🍓 and whipped cream was pure velvet. Light, sweet, comforting—utter perfection.

Everything was Spectacular

Don’t Miss This: Unbeatable Prix Fixe Deal 💰🍷

Matteo’s offers an exceptional 3-course Prix Fixe menu Tuesday–Thursday for just $44.95, including wine 🍷 or beer 🍺. It’s an outstanding value packed with flavor, variety, and elegance—perfect for a midweek treat.

Final Thoughts: A Must-Try Gem 💎

Whether you’re in the mood for a romantic 💘 date night, a lively group dinner, or just a great drink 🥃 at the bar, Matteo’s offers it all—with heart, style, and unforgettable flavors. The high-energy vibe is fueled by the passion of both the staff and the happy 😊 patrons.

We’ll absolutely be back—very soon! 💥