Pellegrino & Son's Pizzeria

Pellegrino is the best pizza place in Middletown NY. Every thing in the menu is delicious. The food is super fresh. The service here is incredibly good. If, you want the very best of everything, you definitely need to come to Pellegrino. The pizza and the food is 100% way better than frank pizza. Frank pizza is horrible and nasty

I ordered delivery: pizza special & a couple of dinners --total over $60. We had stopped using them when their prices went up & the 4% card fee (higher than neighboring places).

Something tasted off with the sauce, today. Thought it was me but my toddler didn't eat the pizza slice either-- called it yucky (the kid loves Pizza). Sauce was salty & without any Italian flavor (oregano, basil, peppers- you name it) and didn't taste tomato-y either. It was a darker red than usual.

The person who answered the phone was nice & patient while I navigated the confusing on line menu.

We use to, and still want to, enjoy their food. If they are trying out a new cook or vendor, please go back to the old one(s).

Had an amazing experience at Pellegrino & Son’s for dinner! It was our first time visiting and the food was delicious. You can tell they use high quality ingredients and that they care very much about their customers. We were treated so kindly. The owner himself took our order and gave us recommendations! The vodka sauce was amazing! As well as the chicken Caesar salad and the pizza slices we got. Saved this place to come back every time we’re in the area!

Hands down the best Pizza in the Hudson Valley!!!!!!! And if you haven't tried Pelldgrino's freshly made sandwich, you are missing out. Fresh Chicken Cutlet, Homemade Bread, Melted Mozzarella, and a mixture homemade sauces to die for.

So I went here yesterday with the intent d just to get a regular slice and my wife ended up getting the some zeppely's and I saw a gentleman leaving with a crazy looking specialty slice that I've ever seen before.
So me being nosy. I asked her guy making a pizza asked him what kind of pizza is that he told me one was. I think I believe a Big Mac pizza and the next one was like a chicken finger with french fries.
And in any case the pizza was beyond good man. It was so so good. He didn't have any slices so he made me a personal one so I had to have half and half split it with one big mac and split the other side with the thing with the chicken fingers and the french fries and the spicy sauce. Man,
It was so good. I used to come here when I used to live in Middletown. Haven't been in a while but they're always consistent man. The food is really really good. The people are really really good and place is just really really good.
He told me he has another slice, some taco slice and some other slice he was talking about. I plan on going there just to taste those but definitely make it your business to check this place out. It's kind of like Brooklyn Pizza.
I say it's the closest thing to Brooklyn Pizza up here. Everything else is maybe like three good spots. I mean upstate and I'm going to say within the Goshen Middletown Chester area. This is one of them. You have one in Middletown, one in Chester and one in Warwick. I don't even think we have one in Chester to be honest, I think it's one in Warwick. There's none in Chester and the next spot is actually in Poughkeepsie