The Pizzeria of Bayport

Review by Izaya, Carol’s Senior Pet Sanctuary

Our team at Carol’s Senior Pet Sanctuary truly appreciates the consistent quality and hospitality we receive from this establishment. Every visit is met with genuine smiles and an uplifting atmosphere, and the food is always excellent. The staff is patient, attentive, and dedicated to ensuring every customer finds exactly what they’re looking for. Everyone behind the counter is a blessing, and their hard work never goes unnoticed. Highly recommended.

Normally I would give 5 stars for food because I have always had great meals here. I came here last Saturday to pick up a bar pie. Ordered through Grubhub. Order would be ready between 8pm-8:10pm. Got there at 8. The pie that the server gave me was sitting in a box on top of 3 others and a couple on top of it so was probably sitting for awhile. Thought nothing of it because it’s always good here, but when I got home the pizza was not edible. Took out 3 slices for me and my family and maybe took 2 bites. Could not eat the crust which I usually love. Hopefully this was a one off. I will go back again but will check it next time

The Pizzeria is hands down the best around! The team is beyond friendly and helpful. Their food is consistently incredible - fresh and flavorful. Whether I’m grabbing a quick bite or ordering for a big event, they never disappoint.

Their catering is truly next level. Professional, reliable, and absolutely delicious every single time. Guests always rave about the food, and I wouldn’t trust anyone else with my events.

If you’re looking for amazing food and service that goes above and beyond, The Pizzeria is the only place to go. I wouldn’t go anywhere else! 🍕👏

This has become one of my favorite pizza spots on Long Island. I DoorDash multiple times a week from them to my office as well as my home. I work in Holbrook and live in ronkonkoma and I still will always support. Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. The buffalo knots are unreal, the broccoli pinwheels are delicious and the chicken rolls are literally the best I’ve had. My fave has to be the vodka sauce sausage crumble slice. The office loves it, my boyfriend and I love it. 10/10 always

Chicken cutlet parm. Stromboli — couldn’t be sure it was really chicken… If it was, it was frozen bits of chicken from a bag at Sam’s Club… Beer was good but only one beer available (Perroni) Pepperoni pinwheel was okay — under cooked and a little mushy, but I think that’s typical for pinwheels unless you hit the pinwheel lotto. Went back up to get a slice and she was like what kinda slice? Uh — cheese. “Oh, you mean regular?” Yes. So, she says have a seat and we’ll bring it to you. I’m like — it’s right there — just came out the oven — I don’t want it too hot. “Oh okay. Jimmy, not too hot.” (They gave me one that was sitting there a while not the fresh one). So, I go sit down and hollers out “regular slice!” Shaking my head. I thought you asked me to sit down so you could bring it to me. Awkward experience, overall. Oh, and the beer tap wasn’t working, so she asked for help and the guy comes over and looks and says just give him the money back. I’m like, you can’t get it working? lol They did get it working. Co2 line wasn’t connected