New jersey

The Sizzle BBQ Argentinian Steak House & Bar

(5 Reviews)
216 Woodside Ave (route, US-206, Newton, NJ 07860, USA

The Sizzle BBQ Argentinian Steak House & Bar is located in Sussex County of New Jersey state. On the street of U.S. 206 For inquiries, you can contact them at (862) 275-7777. You can get more information from their website.
The coordinates that you can use in navigation applications to get to find The Sizzle BBQ Argentinian Steak House & Bar quickly are 41.0398215 ,-74.7644518

Contact and Address

State: New Jersey
Address: 216 Woodside Ave (route, US-206, Newton, NJ 07860, USA
Postal code: 07860
Phone: (862) 275-7777
Website: http://thesizzlebbq.com/

Opening Hours:

Monday:Closed
Tuesday:12:00 – 9:30 PM
Wednesday:12:00 – 9:30 PM
Thursday:12:00 – 9:30 PM
Friday:12:00 – 10:30 PM
Saturday:12:00 – 10:30 PM
Sunday:12:00 – 9:00 PM

Location & routing

The Sizzle BBQ Argentinian Steak House & Bar216 Woodside Ave (route, US-206, Newton, NJ 07860, USA
Get Directions

Users Reviews And Rating

  • Melissa M. H.

    (October 1, 2025, 11:24 pm)

    The star of the night:
    Sizzle MIX Charcoal BBQ Meats 👏🏼 👏🏼 a traditional Argentinian style meal, served on a hot charcoal skillet. The short rib was amazing, great tastes on the meats. CHIMICHURRI SAUCE pairs perfectly with everything.
    The chicken though… tastes too much like… stinky chicken.

    To begin, were celiac. Our first question was, are we safe ordering just bbq meats for a family of 3. (Hubby, myself, child)
    Server was knowledgeable of full menu and had such a great personality. Our order was on point, we were well maintained. Sizzle Mix was huge for all 3 and still had leftovers. Only thing that wasn’t ok to eat for us was the fries.

    Place was small and not crowded at the time of our visit. Very beautiful decor.

    Downside: I opened the ketchup bottle to find a black rim all around the cap inside and on the glass bottle itself. Please clean those. Fruit flies were also lounging on the wall of our table. I killed two of them with a napkin and left it at the end of our table.

    The passionfruit sangria tasted too sweet, less wine. If thats your thing.

    Would visit again, but according to older reviews… I think this is the only thing we would order.

  • Aisha S.

    (September 21, 2025, 9:33 pm)

    I would say that the only thing nice about my experience was the restaurant atmosphere and the design other than that it was lackluster. The waiter was not happy to serve us, he took the menus away after we ordered the appetizers and then again after we ordered not asking if we wanted to hold one for dessert. My steak was super salty and I’m not middle age or senior (no offense guys! Love ya!!) when I told him they didn’t asked if I wanted another they just brought out a new one and when I tell you it was raw…I can still hear the cow in the back. I like medium rare but this was gross. The amount of fat on it was also displeasing, 5% meat the rest was fat.I am not eating anything that someone got mad about because they cooked it wrong and now I might get something “extra”. The chicken was delicious though and the empanadas but it was good but over all just a bad experience. Honestly my first and kinda last time to come in to this place.

  • Jim Newkirk

    (September 6, 2025, 6:16 pm)

    Had one of the best Cuban Sandwiches I have eaten at The Sizzle BBQ Argentinian Steak House. The sandwich is huge. The ingredients (slow cooked pork, ham, and bread) are high quality and delicious. If you want to taste a little bit of Cuba , I would highly recommend stopping at this restaurant.

  • Chuck Mound

    (August 15, 2025, 7:49 pm)

    With thr name Sizzle BBQ, I was expecting somethjng different. They have a menu that is all over the place. We waited at our table for 15 minutes before someone came over. Watched 3 tables who came in after us, get their drink orders and apps before our server came over. Hate when that happens. Though, we must have got the best server in the house because she was on point. Wish I could remeber her name because she was 5 a 5 star server. So that balanced out the bad start. Back to even until we got the cheese nachos. $15 for a Few Chips and some Taco Bell Cheese sauce. Not good. At least use real cheese. The steak Fajitas were very good, so much flavor on the steaks. So that brought it back to an even 3 for a first visit. It was a very busy Friday night, so I can cut some slack. But I would re think the cheese nachos. Was told need to order a steak, will definitely do that next visit and then uodate review.

  • Very Important Reviewer

    (August 4, 2025, 10:12 pm)

    They know how to make a good sandwich, but my praise ends there. Our server was visibly disinterested in my table and brought the entrees out cold. I could see she was distracted sitting on her phone a table away and forgot about us. Not once did she even ask if we wanted refills. Only when it was time for the check did our server’s indifferent personality flip to bright and cheery.

    The barbecue pork entree didn't taste like much at the restaurant since it was served cold, but once I got home and heated up the leftovers to temp next-day, then it was decent. However the bbq chicken was downright bad. It had a bizarre texture that felt and tasted like biting into a waterlogged book. My Buenos Aires sandwich, also despite being served lukewarm, was very good at least. The sauce and bread complimented the meat well.

    Based on this experience, the main thing this bbq joint has going for them is the sandwiches. The Buenos Aires sandwich was really good. Unfortunately the poor service was a real turn-off, so I won't return.

Write a Review

Related Searches