Amalfi Trattoria

This Italian restaurant is a true standout, with warm, friendly vibes and it always feels wonderfully welcoming. The food is exceptional in every sense. Each dish is crafted with care and attention to detail, showcasing fresh ingredients and authentic Italian flavors. The pizza is among the best I’ve had in the area.

The service elevates the experience even further. The staff is attentive without being intrusive, genuinely friendly, and knowledgeable about the menu. They always make me valued and comfortable any time I come in for a visit.

Altogether, this restaurant excels in food, atmosphere, and service. I’d highly recommend for anyone looking for genuine Italian food and a great atmosphere. It’s a regular lunch spot any time Im passing by!

Amalfi Trattoria was an absolutely wonderful experience from start to finish.
The food was outstanding - authentic, full of flavor, and clearly prepared with high-quality ingredients.
Every dish tasted homemade and perfectly balanced, just like true Italian cuisine should be.
The service was excellent: warm, attentive, and genuinely welcoming. I felt taken care of without ever feeling rushed. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, making it the perfect place to enjoy a relaxed and delicious meal.
One of the best Italian meals I've had in New York.
Highly recommended - I will definitely be back!

If you have ever had pizza in NYC then you know the level that pizza can reach. Crunchy tasty bread, fresh ingredients, melt cheese. My mouth waters just thinking about it. When I moved to the Newburgh area I had fears that I would never taste like that pizza again without a journey of at least two hours.

FEAR NOT, people of the area!

Almafi Trattoria does a great job of capturing everything you want from a NYC pizza. The crust has an on-point crunch, the sauce is tangy and not too sweet, and the cheese is wonderfully melty. Do not hesitate to order pizza from here. You're in good hands!

Asidr from pizza, everything we've ordered from here has been delicious! Obviously some items are better eaten in than out, but that's a you problem. We hughly recommend ordering from here.

My #1 recommendation is the Nonna pie. Add pepperoni for perfection.

Highly recommend. Best pizza you can get around here. My girlfriend is Gluten Free too and they accommodated her with GF Penne Ala Vodka and a grilled eggplant Parm, she said it was delicious. 10/10! Go here! Support local business! You WONT get a better slice in the area!