Boxcar Burgers LI

Came in for the bathroom, left with one of the tastiest milkshakes I have had in a while. The people were friendly. The food was good and well priced. The vibe was chill. If you are coming or going from the Ronkonkoma line, stop in.

Wow! I've seen this spot twice on my commute and I am really happy i tried their food. I had sweet potato fries with a cheeseburger and wow it was good. The service here, provided by this sweet young lady who helped at the register made me feel so welcomed, but the entire staff overall was nice. Definitely will be back for more. I had their shake and you can customize it. Honestly this place just has the sweetest people. Please make sure you are kind to them and tip.

tasty burgers for a decent price, place is located right next to the station so parking can be wild but worth it. Definitely would come back !

That was hands-down one of the best burger experiences I’ve ever had.

I stumbled upon this absolute gem—a tiny, hole-in-the-wall spot tucked right beside the train station. Honestly, it looks like nothing special from the outside, but wow, you walk in and you know they are serious about their food.

I ordered their classic cheeseburger, and it was pure perfection. The beef was clearly high quality—juicy, perfectly seasoned, and cooked exactly to my liking. The bun was soft yet held up beautifully, and the toppings were fresh and balanced. This wasn't some generic fast-food patty; this was a gourmet burger experience hiding in plain sight.
What really blew me away, though, was the price. Considering the quality of the ingredients, I expected to pay significantly more. It was an amazing value for a top-tier meal.

If you are ever passing through or waiting for a train, do yourself a favor and stop here. You'd miss it if you weren't looking. This is now my go-to spot. Will definitely be returning—probably next time I'm in the area. Five stars, no question.

Okay spot for a quick bite. The chicken sandwich was unusually smaller than what I would normally expect in places like burger king or chick-fila. I would probably have gone to tap room or the brewery across the street.