City Island Lobster House

Have gone two times in 2024 and enjoyed the time spent there. The food is really great quantity of the portions, will definitely take home some leftovers. I have a great liking to seafood but I have also tried their steak meal during the special deals they have going on during certain times of the year. It was tender and a huge portion of a steak served, not tough to eat at all. Had a basket of raspberry biscuits for the table if I remember correctly. I had yellow rice and veggies with my steak. I enjoyed some dessert and a Sangria that was part of the deal. Can't speak for everyone that I had a lunch and dinner with because its different food items that others ordered and they said they really liked their food. So yes they enjoyed the food also. Good place to go to and eat.
2nd time @ Lobster house I had ordered seafood salad and it was huge, I shared some with the table and still ate plenty and took home leftovers of it too. Seafood salad medley was amazing with shrimp, calamari, clams and mussels and a delish cocktail sauce for the shrimp.

First time visiting and it did not disappoint! The food is excellent and the portions are huge! You will leave stuffed! The garlic bread is awesome! I had the jumbo shrimp Parmesan and it was delicious! When they say jumbo, they mean gigantic! My friend had the special with the lobster tail and it was also delicious! And to top it off, the service was great! Our sever was Oscar and he took care of us! This is definitely a place to try!

We recently visited City Island Lobster House to celebrate a friend’s birthday and had a truly wonderful experience. From the moment we arrived, the staff were exceptionally welcoming, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere.

The food was outstanding — flavorful, well-prepared, and served in shareable portions that made dining together even more enjoyable. Our server, Anthony, was incredibly attentive and knowledgeable. He ensured our table was well taken care of throughout the evening, and our drinks were consistently perfect.

Jojo, the owner, was friendly and approachable, which added a personal touch to our visit. Overall, the atmosphere was vibrant and comfortable, making us feel genuinely appreciated as guests.

I’m already looking forward to my next visit to City Island Lobster House.

Tried it for the first time today Oscar was our server a very professional server very nice man, The food was great , The portions are nice sized and the flavors are excellent, definitely worth going back over and over

Was visitng in the area and stopped by to eat. The last few times we visited City Island, the experience wasn't so great. The good restaurants are long gone and the ones left are commercialized. We decided to stop and grab a bite. It has been a super long time I've dined here. The food was great! Fresh and good portions! Service was great! Danielle was our waitress. She was super friendly and attentive! The white sangria was delicious! It is great to know that there is still a family owned establishment that values great service and even greater food. On our way out we stopped to chat quickly with Joe the owner! Kudos to you and your team! I highly recommend this restaurant! When back in the area, we'll definitely visit again!!