| State: | New York |
|---|---|
| Address: | 325 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770, USA |
| Postal code: | 11770 |
| Phone: | (631) 583-9552 |
| Website: | https://rachelsfireisland.com/ |
The food was consistent and well received, especially the burger and the rigatoni bolognese. The wide selection of desserts from their bakery were a welcome conclusion to our meal. What surprised and disappointed me most about my experience was that my server (Maggie) was sufficiently disappointed with a 15.6% tip that she followed me out of the restaurant and suggested that the tip was insufficient. It was embarrassing in front of family and guests, as well as being unwarranted. Up until that point, the service had been fine, but my experience was quickly ruined.
Went to dinner with friends on 08/12/25. Our waitress was friendly and attentive to our table. The food was spot on. Everyone enjoyed their meal. I would have given them 5 stars but after dinner I went to the bakery, which is connected to the restaurant. I pointed out to the girl the 6 cookies I wanted. Six cookies $23, Ouch! When I got back to my place to my surprise there were only 5 cookies in the bag. The next day I shared the cookies with friends and family. Have to say these cookies had absolutely no taste. Probably some of the worst gourmet cookies I ever tasted. Don’t waste your money in the bakery. Restaurant yes, bakery no.
Walking into Rachel's is like getting a warm hug. The atmosphere is so cozy and inviting, and every dish I've tried has been an absolute winner. The bakery items are truly out of this world—I'm still dreaming about the cinnamon rolls! But what really sets this place apart is the staff. They are so friendly and attentive, making you feel like a valued guest every single time. It's the perfect spot for a casual lunch, a celebratory dinner, or just to grab a coffee and a pastry. A definite must-visit!
Amazing food ,very cozy and comfy place !
Our waitress Sherry was brilliant.
Super funny and very friendly!
That same day we went back for a dinner and we meet Captain Ron .
Omg , he was beyond friendly and welcoming and he is a super star of that place .
Service was amazing!
On your visit to FI Ocean beach you MUST visit.
Defenetly recommend this place !
What an unique experience!
We were looking for a great brunch spot in Fire Island and were pleasantly surprised with what Rachael has to offer. Hands-down the best bloody Mary’s on the island.
Our kids loved the oatmeal and the French toast (even if the French toast for the kids size was too small). We went on a holiday weekend and the wait wasn’t too bad either. It would be great if they had more outdoor seating but The food was very good and worthwhile spot for breakfast or brunch.
Will definitely be back.