Scallywag's

Great Irish American pub. Music. Guinness. Came back for Shepards Pie and sweet potato fries.

Nice Irish bar with a good atmosphere and very friendly/attentive staff. Has good quality live music too. However, prices are on the expensive side; ~$40 including tax/tip for 3 pints feels like a lot, even considering the location (the same round at the closest bar is only $30) especially when all of the drinks were flat. Decent place to pop into but won't necessarily be visiting again.

Great, friendly service! Cozy atmosphere. HUGE portions!!! The french fries are delicious & the fried fish is divine. The grilled salmon salad was perfect & a lot more filling than you’d expect. Irish coffee was hot & strong!

BEST GUINNESS POUR IN NYC HANDS DOWN

Believe me we searched.

You know you’ve reached the right place for a pint when the Irish accents outnumber the rest.

We were in the area for about a week and stopped for a pint of Guinness wherever it presented itself. Many decent pints in the city. This one is the clear winner. Lucky to have Scallywags around the corner from our hotel and able to repeat often throughout our stay.

Comfortable pub feel, impeccably clean lines, sparkling, cold glasses and welcoming bartenders who take care in handing out a proper pour and making you feel, honestly, at home. (Ro and Cathryn are absolute assets!)

$10 *imperial* pints all day. None of the 16oz glasses being handed out for more elsewhere.

Stop by. Your expectations will be exceeded.

Great little traditional Irish pub. Enjoyed a nice Sheperads Pie and the lad from Donegal serving us was very personable.