Ti Amo Pizza

Great pizza and awesome food! Always fresh, tasty, and made just right and the staff is always on point and genuinely nice. One of the best spots in Staten Island definitely worth stopping by.

Ti Amo Pizza is one of those rare spots that just gets it right every single time. From the second you walk in, you’re greeted with genuine warmth; not that forced “hi” you get at chain places, but a real welcome. The staff here is outstanding: fast, friendly, and always on top of things. You can tell they take pride in what they do, and that kind of consistency is hard to come by.

The owner deserves credit too; you can feel his presence in the place. He’s hands-on, engaged, and clearly loves what he’s built. He treats customers like family and runs his shop the way a true New Yorker runs a pizzeria: with pride, hustle, and heart. You don’t see that much anymore.

Now, the pizza perfection. This is exactly what NYC pizza should be: thin yet sturdy, a perfect balance of sauce and cheese, and that subtle char on the crust that tells you it came out of a proper oven, not a conveyor belt. You get that first bite, and it’s everything you expect; cheesy, flavorful, and full of that classic New York character. It’s the kind of slice that makes you pause mid-conversation because you’re too busy appreciating how good it is.

I’ve been here several times now, and what really blows me away is how consistent it is. The pies are always fresh, the portions are fair, and even during busy hours, they don’t cut corners. That’s the sign of a place that cares about its product. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or sitting down for dinner, you get the same level of quality every single time.

The atmosphere fits perfectly clean, casual, family-friendly, but with that old-school pizzeria charm. You can bring friends, family, or just stop in solo after a long day and know you’re going to leave satisfied. It’s that kind of comfort food spot that makes you feel at home.

Ti Amo Pizza has easily become one of my go-to places on Staten Island. The food speaks for itself, the service backs it up, and the people behind it make it worth supporting. This is the kind of small business that reminds you why local spots will always beat the big chains.

If you’re looking for real New York pizza not the imitation kind this is the place. Every visit has been solid from start to finish, and I honestly could eat here every day. Highly recommend.

This is by far the best pizzeria on Staten Island. From start to finish I can’t recommend this pizzeria enough. The staff is very friendly and welcoming and the pizza is delicious! The pizza tastes fresh and full of authentic ingredients! I highly recommend this pizzeria!!

Alrivera approved. Had a wonderful experience. Stop by if u r around. 100% alrivera approved.

Want authentic Brooklyn style pizza? This is your place! We had the pepperoni roll, margherita & white slice so friggin’ delicious OMG that crust so crispy! Delicious NOT greasy, salty, flimsy or dry. Made to perfection . We carried out vodka & pepperoni pie. The friendly staff and the cleanliness of the place is a plus. So glad my son and I stopped here before heading back to Jersey. We will definitely be back thank you TI AMO pizza! 😀