Umberto's Restaurant & Pizzeria

Best NY style pizza on LI.

Best selection, best quality, just the absolute best. The pazzo slice is phenomenal. Their ala vodka grama style is perfect. Thin , crispy and with the perfect fold.

Don't get me wrong, there's better in Brooklyn but on the island, Umberto's takes the cake hands down.

My wife and I enjoyed a nice dinner at this restaurant. Despite being a busy Friday night, we were served quickly and we didn't have to wait long for our food.

I had meatball parm with spaghetti and my wife had some kind of chicken dish thing....I dont know what it was...but we enjoyed our food, the cleanliness of the facility and the attractive dining room.

I felt that the portions...at least mine...was a little too small, but the high quality of the ingredients more than made up for it.

I would definitely go back again and we will the next time we are in the area and thinking about Italian food.

Thank you Umbertos...for a nice evening out.

Umberto’s is hands down one of the best pizza spots in Wantagh. I’ve tried a lot of local places, and nothing really comes close, definitely way better than Phil’s down the street. The pizza here is everything you want: crispy crust, perfectly melted cheese, and sauce that actually has flavor. You can tell they use quality ingredients and really take their time with it. It’s not just the pizza either, all of their food options are delicious. Whether it’s pasta, heroes, or something quick from the counter, it all tastes fresh and made with care. The only thing I’d say is it’s a tiny bit pricey, but honestly, the flavor and quality totally make up for it. You’re paying for good food, and you can taste it. The staff were super nice and respectful when I came in, and they had my order ready fast. The place itself has a really open, calm atmosphere, not loud or cramped like a lot of other pizzerias. It’s easy to figure out where to order and where to pick up your food, which makes it super convenient if you’re in a rush. Plus, they have a wide selection of food ready to go if you just walk in without ordering ahead. Overall, Umberto’s is one of those places you can count on every single time. Great food, great service, and a solid vibe all around. Highly recommend to anyone in the area looking for top-quality pizza.

Oscar was amazing and so warm. We will definitely go back when we visit again from South Carolina!