Old Stone House Restaurant Warwick NY

I’m not one to leave bad reviews but this was a doozy. To the wait staff and front-of-house, they did their best and clearly work very hard, especially our waitress. She’s one waitress to an entire room of 5-6 large tables. Our reservation was for 3pm, we did not receive our food until 4:15pm.

The Thanksgiving special was $45 per plate and these were the portion sizes (pictured). Overloaded with stuffing and green beans, bone dry cornbread, and a small of amount of the rest. I asked the waitress for more turkey, as I was not satisfied with the pictured portion. She was happy to get me some but when she returned, she said she was told “portions are what they are.” We were also told over the phone that dessert was included with the Thanksgiving special, and shocker it was actually not.

Charging egregious prices while being stingy with protein portions is never a good look.

Just went for the first time last night, the food is delicious, the staff is professional, and the atmosphere is perfect. Not only did they accommodate us arriving way too early for our reservations, but they also took great care in making us feel welcome! Our waitress Agi (sorry if I spelled that wrong) was delightful; and the kitchen accommodated my allergy requests. Thanks for having us, and a big thank you to the manager/hostess…I’m sorry I didn’t get your name!

photos: dining room fireplace / roasted beet medley / baked cod / short rib

Okay, so I may be getting snooty as I get older but I expect a drink order taken within 5 or 10 minutes of getting to an eating establishment. 20 minutes went by before we placed our drink orders. When getting a second round, 30 minutes elapsed before they showed up. The appetizers were solid and the deserts were fantastic. The main courses were delicious but small portions for the money. I do highly recommend the Almond old fashioned. All in all not a bad experience but, I'm glad we weren't on a time crunch. Will be back for drinks and apps.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
The Old Stone House is an absolute gem! The food was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. The service was warm, attentive, and genuinely welcoming. The atmosphere is cozy yet elegant, with a charming historic feel that makes the experience truly special. Every detail showed care and quality. Highly recommended for anyone looking for a memorable dining experience—I’ll definitely be coming back!

Went for lunch and ended up having brunch. The food was good. I had the Eggs Benedict with salmon, and my companions had crepes and avocado toast. The staff was pleasant and friendly. The bathroom was spotless. The building is lovely and restored from a practically deliric building. I would definitely recommend. Be aware It is pricey and they charge for every cup of coffee no refills.