BAYVILLE ITALIAN BAKERY & GOURMET DELI

The food here is very good, but the experience was disappointing. Customer service was poor—my order was ready, yet a staff member on the phone completely ignored me. This felt especially unfair since I drove 37 miles just to try the food I saw online. Prices are a bit high, too, with a sub costing $32.95. The food is worth trying, but the service definitely needs improvement

🥪💛

Stopped by Bayville Deli today and must say everything I have eaten so far has been absolutely delicious! We got a large plain pie and a buffalo chicken pie both superb. Got buffalo wings and garlic parm wings (both buffalo sauce and garlic parm sauce on the side) the wings were soooo good. Crispy! The buffalo sauce was soo good and the garlic parm was good but not garlicky enough. Got meatballs and chicken cutlets from the deli so will post tomorrow about those. About to eat a chocolate cannoli. Can’t wait. It was a little pricey but the food was good so can’t complain

Bagel with olive cream cheese was amazing. Owner is nice and place has all sorts of stuff. I will definitely be returning.

Gotta say I’m impressed. Pizza was really good. Also bought a wrap and a sub and they were amazing. Didn’t think they even sold pizza until I went inside. Overall if you like tasty quality food then deff try them out.

We ordered 3 half subs (Italian, chicken Fat Sal, and the 23). The food was amazing! The chicken cutlets were moist and flavorful, the mozzarella was excellent, the bread was delicious! The sandwiches were huge and we couldn’t finish them so we have enough for a second meal which makes the cost totally worth it! Our only complaint was the grumpy guy behind the counter making our sandwiches. The rest of the staff were friendly and accommodating. We will definitely be back despite the grump.