PrimoHoagies

This was my first time ever there and I told the woman at the register. Her service was fantastic, but the sandwich was horrible. I wish I took a picture!

First of all the sandwich was drenched in oil, so much oil that there was a puddle in the paper which leaked out onto my shirt and the car seat and that’s when I was like WTH. I literally had to pull over to eat it because there was no way to eat this thing with one hand. My hands were covered in oil from just picking it up. The bread was also soggy because of it.

There was SO much mustard on the sandwich that one bite I took was just all mustard… and to top it off the lettuce and tomato was just laying on top of this fully packed sandwich. I couldn’t even close it to bite it and ended up picking the toppings off the top by finger and eating it. The lettuce was also drenched in oil.

Too sloppy and I was not a fan at all. I’ve heard great things about this chain and I cannot agree. I’ve literally been complaining about this sandwich all day to anyone who would listen lol

They make the best sandwiches around, takes Jersey Mike's out by far. Way fresher then your average very clean and fast service.
The best thing about them is they don't skimp out on the sandwich by any means you get what you pay for and then some I always get the turkey and provolone with salami and everything on it on a Italian seeded bread whole and it feeds up to 8 People for the price it's amazing. So good I drive a Hour away just to get it the best location is West Orange I must say!!! Keep up the good work and I will continue to bring my business family and friends in for sure I wish I could give them 100 stars 🤩

We ordered the Mild Sharp Italian and the Whacked Chicken. The Italian tasted good and it was fully packed. However, the cheese was sliced very thick and the pickles were just strangely thrown on top. The Whacked Chicken was an absolute mess. The best way to describe it is that no one cared about it. There was juice and oil all over, the bread was soggy and it had to be eaten with a knife and fork. It was not appetizing or appealing to look at. Also, good thing we didn’t open this in the car!
This was our first experience at a Primo Hoagies and it wasn’t the best first impression. Based on these 2 sandwiches, there doesn’t seem to be consistency or standards- the sandwiches look NOTHING like the pictures on the website.