Cold Spring Cheese Shop

Great selection of cheeses and crackers, and the employees were very helpful with giving recommendations based on my particular needs. Prices were decent as well. Great for picking up a little nibble with wine.

Incredible Cheese shop, very impressed. I highly recommend the homemade Mac and cheese as well as the sandwiches

Great selection of cheese and other gourmet products. Special sandwich was very deliscious.

I stopped by Cold Spring Cheese Shop on a Sunday morning and tried their “special sandwich” Rusted Red Denners, pesto, goat chevre, arugula, balsamic, and olive oil. While I appreciated the creativity, the bread didn’t meet my expectations, and I was disappointed that they don’t allow any modifications or substitutions for the ingredients. Because of that, I’ve decided I won’t be returning.

My time at Cold Spring was a little bittersweet. Many of the places I visited were either a hit-or-miss, but luckily this establishment was one of the good ones.

They had a ton of cheese options and a pretty nice selection of meats and fruit preserves. I bought a few things here like a bottled iced tea, bag of Torres black truffle potato chips, and the mozzarella w/ fig jam sandwich which was fantastic.

They seemed to be too busy to provide samples when I came here this past Saturday with a lot of other NYC tourists, but it would've been great to try some of the cheese options because I probably would've bought a few types, but I'm still happy I went and at least tried a sandwich.

I would definitely recommend coming here if you're visiting.