Pike Pizza And Grill

Been ordering from here since we moved into Dingmans Ferry 2 years. Love the burger deal and the pizza is pretty good. Today we tried the Smoke House pizza and everyone in the house loved it. What a great combination of ingredients. Will definitely be getting it again.

Can't claim it's the best pizza I've ever had and the hours are weird (order before 7 or your options are limited as they shut the grill off around this time)... but the quality is consistent and their pizza is pretty good considering where the place is and how remote everything in this area tends to be.

Prices are reasonable and the staff is polite and food comes out quickly. I'd recommend trying the chicken parm pizza, not something I'd normally try, but I think it was the best I've had here. 😋

Bought the weekly meal deal that is 4 burgers w. fries. Fries are good and burger meat is good. The only negative note is they put a quarter size tomato and 4 rings of onion.

I tried this place for the first time last Saturday night. It was 30 minutes before closing, so I didn't experience the atmosphere. The staff didn't mind that it was almost closing time and the toppings were still fresh. I've been eating NY and NJ pizza for decades and this is the closest I've had, in that area. I can't compare it to my normal pie but it was pretty good on its own. Thick but not heavy and dense. It could've used a little more sauce, but it's the same in my part of Jersey. At most places, I have to ask for a little extra sauce. I'm used to that old school, messy, greasy pie that drips orange grease on my shirt. Other than Dominics in Hillside, NJ, that isn't common anymore.
Anyway, I would go back because of the value and the outstanding sausage. I had a large, Supreme that comes with 4 toppings and it was just under $20, if I remember correctly. No complaints and I would go back.

I gave them 5 stars on “atmosphere” because I did takeout, it didn’t enter into the equation and I didn’t want anything to affect my five star review.

I’m a NY boy; I know from good pizza. Since moving here five years ago I’ve been to every local pizza joint and have experienced anywhere from “awful” to “pretty good” pizza. I tried Pike Pizza last night on a whim. Woah! Not only the BEST pizza I’ve had since moving here but honestly on a par with some of the best I’ve had in NY. And that’s saying something!