Stillwater Cafe

We have been here a couple times now. If you are looking for something unique and fun check it out. It seems like it’s off the beaten path but not really. Dining in a General Store from the 1800’s is pretty cool but let’s talk about the food and host. Dave has done a great job creating dishes with care and our experience has been nothing but positive. Plan ahead as you need to order before you arrive and seating is limited but so worth the experience. Seems like he has a solid repeat following too which speaks volumes to the care Dave puts into his weekly dinner menus. Sincere and genuine guy that obviously loves what he is doing.

What an amazing gem hidden in a small town!
We went to visit family in the area and there’s not much around, but there was this general store, turned cafe. We were arriving on a Saturday and my aunt asked if we wanted to try dinner at the cafe. You reserve your spot and place your order ahead of time. There's only one seating for dinner but you are served a one of a few choices for each course of the 4-course meal (appetizer, salad, entree with two sides, and dessert).

For the appetizer, I ordered the shrimp cocktail. It was a good, standard shrimp cocktail. My wife had the Mushroom & Herb Cream Cheese Crostini, which she loved.

Next we were served the salad with Mixed Greens, Watermelon, Almond & Feta with Balsamic Dressing. It was very light and refreshing. Amazing flavor combinations.

For the entree, my wife and I both ordered the beef short rib. Simply amazing. It was fork tender, wonderful flavor and topped with gravy. The sides were Brussel sprouts on top of shredded carrots, and a bacon cheddar potato. Every thing was cooked to perfection. (The kids both got the Chicken Parmigiana and loved it)

For dessert, we strategized and got two of each dessert to split between the four of us. Creme Brulee Raspberries and
Chocolate Panna Cotta with Mandarin Orange & Cream. All I can say is we wish we got four of each. We split them and they were both so delicious, we wished there was more to go around. The portions were great and we were already stuffed from the meal, but that didn’t stop us from all cleaning our dessert plates.

(The location is BYOB. The are sodas, juice and water on location, but bring your own alcohol.)

My husband and I enjoyed a delicious 4-course prix fixed dinner for our anniversary. The communication and service around the meal was warm and friendly, and my food allergy needs were met without issue. We will definitely return soon!

My husband and I had a delicious 4-course meal at a very reasonable price. The chef was super nice and accommodating to my dietary needs. Historic building in a quaint little town. We'll be back!

I’ve had bacon all over the world. New York. London. LA. Berlin. I still dream about the Bacon here that we ate waiting for our Philly friends to show up for a hike. The home fries were great too. Only been once, but would make a detour to go again if I’m in the area and hungry.