The Amish Dutch Wagon

The place is small and always seems to be crowded. The food is what I go for, it is a bit more expensive than the super market, but in my opion its a much higher quality so worth the extra money. And the soft pretzels are amazing

A Truly Authentic Experience!
What a wonderful discovery!
Amish Wagon offers genuinely authentic Amish cuisine that takes you straight to the heart of traditional cooking. Every dish we tried was absolutely delicious – you can taste the quality and care in every bite.
What makes this place extra special is the authenticity – real Amish folks working here, bringing their heritage and expertise to every aspect of the experience.

Chef Jacob was particularly outstanding, personally serving us in the dining area with such warmth and genuine hospitality. His passion for the food and dedication to guests really shines through.
If you’re looking for honest, home-style Amish cooking and a truly authentic dining experience, this is the place. The food is exceptional, the atmosphere is welcoming, and the people make you feel like family.
Highly recommend!

It's not a huge place, but it's jam packed with goodies. Cooked foods, butcher and deli, cheeses, bakery, ice cream, coffee, fresh fruits and vegetables. Everyone I met was pleasant. Easy parking. Go hungry!

This market is unique and there are items that you can't get in other specialty markets. They have spices, chocolate, homemade sides and salads, and much more. Try the Rotisserie chicken. I bought a chicken breast and it was fresh, moist and delicious. Perfect for summer salads. They have a bakery, hand dipped ice cream, and handmade soft pretzels. If you haven't already, take a ride and sample all that this market has. Staff are so nice too.

09/2023: My picky husband and daughter loved the Ribeyes and cheddar cheese burgers. And every time I shopped there, Apple dumplings are a must-bye for my husband, soft pretzels and cheese hotdogs are also something I would like to buy.

At this time, Jersey peaches are delicious! The figs I bought were tree-ripen and tasted so sweet! Loved everything here!

Update 1/19/2021: Ever since I first came here over a year ago, I have been going regularly to stock my pork, beef, chicken and rabbit. They are all very good quality and good service! If there’s anything specific you want, you can always call ahead to ask and/or order.

Ice cream and raw honey are very good too.

12/20/2019: It’s the first time we came here today. We bought a lot of pork, bacon, souse, chicken wings and stewer, pie, cookies and bread, pretzels and pretzel hotdogs. Too many things to choose. But we didn’t realize that the shed by the entrance to the markets was a store selling vegetables and fruits until I looked at the pictures later and found out.

Everything seemed very nice. And the price was not bad to me.

So far we have tried the pretzels and pretzel hotdogs, almond cookies, chicken wings and pork “wings”. They are very good especially the pretzels, soft and moist enough but without a lot of baking soda like others. Delicious!

I will update about the meats and others.