Setauket Village Diner Restaurant

What a great spot! Our waitress Terry was incredible-went above and beyond excellent service! We had a wonderful experience thanks to all. Highly highly recommend🩷

I had breakfast it was around 11 in the morning. My husband had lunch. The place is beautiful the service over the top. Food was delicious. My pancakes could have been a pinch hotter. My husband's burger was fantastic the potato salad was so so good. I will be going back to try other dishes. Loved the coffee

Great little place. Didn't know what to expect, but I'm thoroughly impressed. Service, impressive. Very attentive and polite servers. The owner even came by to chat with us. Food is delicious. With a large menu selection, i usually have my doubts. But I went with the North Shore chicken and it was delicious. I'm sad i was too full to try dessert.

Old school Greek diner. Gorgonzola Burger was very good. Breakfast is(of course) served all day. Good Coffee. Really like the service..very family like atmosphere.

Setauket Village Diner was a bit of a mixed experience. The place itself is very small for a diner, and while the food was your typical average diner fare, a few things made the visit feel off. During our meal, the back door was left open, and someone was revving an engine so aggressively that the fumes wafted into the restaurant. After politely asking the GM to close the door. The vibe was kind of ruined.

That said, our server was genuinely sweet and respectful. She kept our coffee cups full and made sure we were taken care of, which we appreciated.

Overall, I’m unsure if I’d return, especially with so many other options out there. There are countless places to spend our money, and this visit didn’t quite leave the best impression.