Nicola's Italian Restaurant And Catering

Service and food was very good with large portions given. We will definitely be back.

My only goal when my family visited New York was to try authentic Italian food. Our last night there we found Nicola’s and I feel like we hit the jackpot! The food was incredible! Best Italian food I have ever had! The staff was soo friendly and kind they made us feel like family. And it was extremely reasonably priced! I really can’t say enough good things about this amazing family owned restaurant. 100 stars!

Our first time coming here. The food was AMAZING! We had the calamari, chicken cacciatore, and chicken parm. Cappuccino was delicious! Great service from our waitress Tiffany. Everyone was friendly. Family-friendly environment. Very cozy. Everything was perfect. Highly recommend!

Sunday afternoon lunch/ dinner was so delicious. The blackened salmon was excellent. Atmosphere is nice and relaxing. LILLY not only is the best server, (family business) she makes the best cappuccino!

Nicola’s is as classic as an Italian restaurant can be. The service is awesome and the food is no frills, hearty, well portioned and flavorful.

This was my first time dining here but Nicolas came highly recommended. The atmosphere is warm and quaint, the bread was plentiful, and the entree portions were generous. (I was the only member of the clean plate club in my 5 person party).

The price is right, the energy is wonderful, and the food is classic Italian American. This place is no BS - served with a soup or house salad on the side. This experience was complete with classic plastic PepsiCola cups and garlic knots even your Nonna would love.

I will be returning the first chance I get.